[ Contents | Administrivia | The Shadow | Non-Dark | Sources | Prophecy | Publishing ]

PLEASE NOTE: This version of the FAQ is now outdated; go directly to the current version or see the Welcome Page for more information. (November 2010)

2.6.8: Who betrayed Egwene?

[Leigh Butler, Drew Holton]

The big cliffhanger of COT leaves us with several questions, but the central one is this: who ratted out Egwene's Sooper Sekrit Plan?

There are several possibilities, both for who the traitor was on the Rebel AS side and who captured Eg (and probably Leane too) on the Tower AS side (obviously, each influences the other).

There are also a couple of significant events preceding the operation that probably have something to do with the betrayal. One is the death of Kairen Stang [COT: 30, What the Oath Rod Can Do, 652], who was supposed to be Leane's counterpart in the undertaking. Another is Nicola Treehill's disappearance. Yet another is the unexplained absence of Faolain.

One thing to note at the outset: Egwene's captors are surprised at her identity. Some people have taken this to mean that the capture itself was unplanned, and the AS who captured her were just guarding the wall or something - i.e. there was no betrayal. However, this is highly improbable. The use of forkroot means that the ambush was almost certainly planned, rather than being merely fortuitious - as Ben Goodman points out, forkroot has to be brewed into a tea, which is kind of difficult to carry around "just in case". The precision of the abduction and the lack of a general alarm also suggest that they were forewarned of the plan. It's very unlikely Egwene's captors were there by happenstance; their surprise merely indicates that neither the traitor nor her collaborators on the other side knew about Egwene's last-minute decision to replace Bode.

Who knew about the plan?

Siuan, Leane, Bode, and Kairen Stang (before she died) also knew, obviously, since they were key players in the plot. Gareth Bryne was in on it [COT: 30, What the Oath Rod Can Do, 664], as was Theodrin; presumably the mysteriously absent Faolain was aware of the plan as well, though we can't know that for sure.

There is also a possibility that Nicola (and Areina) knew.

Which of these could be the traitor(s)?

A few of these people can be eliminated outright as suspects. Kairen, being dead and all, can be safely rejected. There's no way Siuan was responsible. Gareth Bryne, Leane and Bode are all extremely unlikely culprits as well. Let's look at the remaining suspects.

1. Nicola: She certainly seems to have been set up to look like she did it. Besides being a malcontent and a known blackmailer, she ran away from the Rebel camp three or four days before Egwene's capture, which would have given her plenty of time to get to the Tower and spill the beans about the plan. As to how she would know about the plan, Nicola has a history of ferreting out information she has no business knowing. It's also possible she learned about it through a Foretelling:

   [Tiana, to Egwene]: "Ever since we found out she has the Foretelling, she's been Foretelling two or three times a day, to hear her tell it. ... battles with the Seanchan or the Asha'man, an Amyrlin imprisoned..." [COT: 17, Secrets, 431, emphasis mine]

   It's been pointed out that Nicola doesn't remember what she Foretells, but Areina or her "family" were clearly telling her everything she said while tranced out, so that's no obstacle. Indeed that brings up another suspicious connection: Sheriam fiercely lobbies Egwene to let Nicola's "cousins" off the hook for covering up her escape. This could be just because Sheriam's own beatings have left her super-sensitive (so to speak) on the issue of corporeal punishment, but another way to look at it is that she is worried about what they might reveal under duress about either Nicola's escape or her other Foretellings, or both [Patrick Cotrona].

   Of course, it could also be that Nicola did run away to the Tower, but had nothing to do with the betrayal. She may have guessed what her "Amyrlin imprisoned" prophecy meant and simply decided to pick the winning side before it all went down. She could even have gone to the Tower in order to help Egwene, unlikely as that may seem.

2. Sheriam: It seems like she could only be the traitor if she is Black Ajah, since the First Oath should otherwise prevent her from breaking her oath of fealty to Egwene so blatantly. Possibly, though, she could have had the information forced out of her by her tormentor, without knowing what he/she was going to do with it. If her torturer is Halima, though (as seems likely - see section 1.5.4), Sheriam being involved in the betrayal would be redundant. Also see the possible Nicola connection, above.

3. Lelaine: After having been so respectful for so long (if reluctantly) since the War Vote, the thinly veiled contempt Lelaine displays for Egwene at their meeting in COT is rather startling. She also makes an ominously ambiguous comment that seems very close to an open threat:

   "The White Tower makes mistakes upon ocasion. It is impossible to live or move without making mistakes. But we live and we go on, and if we sometimes need to conceal our mistakes, whenever possible, we rectify them. Even when it is painful."
   [COT: 30, What the Oath Rod Can Do, 672]

4. Romanda: Romanda was infuriated by Egwene's revelation about the Kin, the Oath Rod, and her idea that Aes Sedai nearing the lifespan limit imposed by the OR could unswear the Oaths and retire into the Kin:

   "When I was a little girl, I dreamed of becoming Aes Sedai. From the day I reached the White Tower, I tried to live as an Aes Sedai. I have lived as Aes Sedai, and I will die as Aes Sedai. This cannot be allowed!"
   [COT: 30, What the Oath Rod Can Do, 668]

5. Faolain: Faolain going MIA, together with her Red sympathies and her general bad attitude, certainly throws some suspicion her way. On the other hand, her absence could also add to the case for Lelaine. Faolain was supposed to be watching the Sitter; her disappearance could indicate that Lelaine got her out of the way (or, alternately, that she was collaborating with Lelaine).

6. Theodrin: Not much of a case for her, other than Egwene musing that she might be getting intentionally careless about watching Romanda (but then, who wouldn't hate that job?), and Rich Boyé's conviction that Theodrin is way too nice to be a good guy. But it is a possibility.

7. Delana/Halima: The strongest evidence in her favor is that Halima murdered Kairen Stang the night before the plan was to go into effect, thus eliminating one of the strongest cuendillar-makers in the Rebel camp and forcing Egwene to fall back on a half-trained novice as backup. (It evidently didn't occur to her that Egwene would decide to take over from Bode, though, since about the only good thing about Eg's capture is that it takes her out from under Halima's eye.)

   Halima would definitely have wanted the plan to fail and keep the two factions deadlocked, but in a strange way that counts as evidence against her - the capture of any Rebel AS, especially two who know how to Travel and make cuendillar, gives a distinct advantage to the Tower faction. Halima's interest is in keeping the conflict at a stalemate. Wouldn't a more efficient way of thwarting the plan while still giving no advantage to either side be to kill Leane and Bode, too? Why only Kairen?

8. Random Sitter: As noted, all the Sitters knew about the plan, and any one of them could have decided to turn traitor, though it's true that most of them would not have made a move without Lelaine or Romanda's say-so. Several people have suggested that the betrayal could be tied in with the still-unsolved Sitter/Ajah Head Mystery that extends to both sides of the conflict (see section 2.6.5).

Who are her captors?

Does the method of the capture itself shed any light on who's responsible? Well, that's a subject of some debate.

"She had just time to realise that someone had embraced the Source not far away, above her on the wall, then something struck the boat, struck her, and she was aware of cold water enveloping her, filling her nose, her mouth. Darkness." [COT: 30, What the Oath Rod Can Do, 677]

It's not quite as clear-cut as that, though. There's no reason to doubt that the AS on the wall used the OP to sink the boat, but the phrase "struck her" is ambiguous. Eg is very disoriented at that point, and the second she feels something hit her she realizes she is in the water. So what "struck her" could have been her body hitting the water.

But even so, Sebastian Redl argues, an attack on the boat constitutes using the OP as a weapon: "Remember the passage earlier in the book where Egwene and Bryne watch the ships going to the harbor. Egwene then thinks that a sister could probably not even make herself form the weaves to sink ship because of the mere possibility! that the crew might drown [COT: 16, The Subject of Negotiations, 393]. There was a possibility that Egwene would drown too."

Jeff Taylor counters, "This is not really Black Ajah evidence. Aes Sedai seem to take a very narrow view on the Third Oath. As long as the attempt was not to kill her outright, an AS can use the Power to attack her without it qualifying as being 'used as a weapon.' If the Aes Sedai just wanted to sink the boat, they probably could do it, as long as they didn't 'intend' to kill anyone." It's also worth pointing out that the possibility of Egwene drowning, close to the wall, with a bunch of AS standing by to fish her out of the drink, was much more remote than the possibility that multiple panicking sailors on a ship sinking far out in the middle of the river would drown.

And any interpretation of the Third Oath that allows for locking someone in a box and beating them repeatedly is probably loose enough to allow for sinking a boat under someone, as long as you have every intention of rescuing them.

The forkroot is similarly inconclusive. Every AS in the Tower, BA or otherwise, knows about the drug by now, and AS queasiness about its existence is not reason enough to suppose they would refuse to use such a surefire and energy-efficient method of containing a renegade channeler.

Can Eg escape by Dreaming?

Yeah, but she doesn't need to channel to enter T'A'R the regular way, does she? So she could go find Elayne or Avi or someone in their sleep and raise the alarm, right?

This was the subject of some debate, but Peter Reid observes, "What everyone who's arguing this point is missing is the fact that it appears that when one is loaded up with forkroot, one cannot Dream. Recall that when Nynaeve captures Moghedien, she feeds her forkroot in T'A'R, which not only takes away her ability to channel, but also causes her to have to leave T'A'R. I think it's said that forkroot puts you into too deep a sleep to be able to enter T'A'R.

"So the whole point is moot. As long as Egwene is being fed forkroot, she won't be able to channel or to Dream. If they decide to stop the forkroot and shield her the traditional way, then she should be able to return to Dreaming."

[ Previous Section | Previous | Section Contents | Next | Next Section ]

[ Contents | Administrivia | The Shadow | Non-Dark | Sources | Prophecy | Publishing ]

Illustrations © 1989-2000 by Tor Books.